¡@¡@ °ªÂIºô¸ô®Ñ©±¡G ±M·~ªk¾Ç¥Xª© > °]¸gªk > ¶i¶¥¬ã²ß
     
 
Ävª§ªk»P´¼¼z°]²£ªk¤§¥æ·|¢w¬Û¥Í»P¬Û«g¤§¶¡
 
Ävª§ªk»P´¼¼z°]²£ªk¤§¥æ·|¢w¬Û¥Í»P¬Û«g¤§¶¡
 
¡i§@ªÌ¡j ¶À»Ê³Ç   ©µ¦ù¾\Ū
¡i®Ñ¸¹¡j 5D163GB
¡i¾A¥Î¡j ¶i­×¬ã²ß 
¡i¥Xª©ªÀ¡j ¤¸·Ó¥Xª©
¡i¥Xª©¡j 2009/4
  9 §é¯S»ù¡G702¤¸ ( ©w»ù 780 )
 
±ÀÂË¡G ¡D°ò¥»Åv°ò¦²z½×¤§Ä~¨ü»P®i±æ¡Ð¥x¤é¤ñ¸û
 
 


ª¾ÃѸgÀٮɥN¸Ì¡A´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¥H±Æ¥L¡]¿W¥e¡^Åvµ¥¤§½á¤©¬°»¤¦]¡A¹ªÀyª¾ÃѪº³Ð·s¬ãµo¡A«P¶i²£·~»P¤å¤Æµo®i¡C±©¦¹Ãþ±Æ¥L¡]¿W¥e¡^Åv­Y¾D¤£·íÀݥΡA¶Õ±N¯}ÃaÄvª§ªk¨î©Ò±ýºûÅ@¤§¥«³õÄvª§¯´§Ç¡A§á¦±Ävª§¾÷¨î¦³®Ä¤À°tªÀ·|µ}¤Ö¸ê·½¤§¥\¯à¡A¶i¦ÓªýêªÀ·|¡B¸gÀÙªº°·¥þµo®i¡C¦p¦ó¥­¿Å´¼¼z°]²£ªk»PÄvª§ªk¤§³W½d¡A©óºûô³Ð·s¬ãµo»¤¦]ªº¦P®É¡A¨Ã°ò©óÄvª§²z©À«P¶i¬ãµoÄvª§¡A¹ê¬°ª¾ÃѸgÀٮɥN½Ò¤©§^¤H¤§½ÒÃD¡C¥»®Ñ¦¬¿ý§@ªÌªñ¦~¨Ó¦³Ãö¦¹¤@½ÒÃD¤§«ä¦Ò¦¨ªG¡A§@ªÌ¥H¨ä¤@³eµR§Q¤§µ§Ä²¡A§å§P¦UºØ¥i¯à¯}Ãa¤Gªk³W½d§¡¿Åªº¥ßªk»P¹ê°È¹B§@¡A¯S§O¬O§Ú°ê³Ì°ªªk°|¦³Ãö©ó¦¹¤§§P¨M¡A§Æ¾¬´£¨Ñ°ê¤º¾Ç¬É¡B¹ê°È¬É¥t¤@ºØ¤£¦PªººØ«ä¦Ò¤è¦V¡C§Ú°ê¦æ¬F¡B¥ßªk¡B¥qªk³¡ªù¡A¬O§_¤w¨ã³Æ¥¿½T»P°·¥þªº»{ÃÑ»P¤ßºA¡A±o¥H¦³®Ä¦^À³ª¾ÃѸgÀٮɥNªº¬D¾Ô¡AŪªÌ©Î¥iÂǥѥ»®Ñ¤@¿s¨s³º¡C

PART I¡þCOMPETITION LAW AND POLICY

°²¦p³o¬O¯uªº¡I¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¾A¥Î©ó¬Fªv¦æ¬°¡þ3
±q³W¨îªºÄvª§ÁÚ¦V³W¨îªº¦X§@¸¨¸}©ó³W¨îªº¿Ä¦X¦^À³Åv¤­­¼±Ð±Â¡uªF¨È¦@¦P¥«³õªº§Î¦¨»PÄvª§ªkªº½ÒÃD¡v¤@¤å

³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ17
¶L¡B«Ø¥ßªF¨È¦@¦P¥«³õ»P²Î¤@Ävª§ªk¨î©Ò­±Á{¤§¬D¾Ô¡þ18
°Ñ¡BÄvª§ªkªº¦X§@»P¿Ä¦X¡þ26
¸v¡Bµ² »y¡þ35

Ävª§ªk¥DºÞ¾÷Ãö§@¬°¿W¥ß¦æ¬F¾÷Ãö¤§¾Ë¬F²Õ´©w¦ì¤Î¨ä¥¿·íªk«ßµ{§Ç
„o¤é¥»¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|¤§µo®i¸gÅç»P±Ò¥Ü
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ39
¶L¡B¤é¥»¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|¤§²Õ´©w¦ì»P¤º»Õ¤§¦æ¬FÅv¡þ43
°Ñ¡B¤é¥»¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|¤§Åv­­¦æ¨Ï»P¥¿·íªk«ßµ{§Ç¡þ55
¸v¡B¹ê½èÃÒ¾Úªk«h»P¥qªk¼f¬d¡þ69
¥î¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ72

Áp¦X¦æ¬°¦¨¥ß»P¥«³õ¬É©w¡B¼vÅT¥«³õ¥\¯à»{©w¶¡¤§²z½×»P½×²z
„oµû³Ì°ª¦æ¬Fªk°|¤E¤Q¤G¦~«×§P¦r²Ä¤@¤T¤T¤»¸¹§P¨M
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ81
¶L¡B§P¨MµûªR¡þ85
°Ñ¡Bµ² »y¡þ115

¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|·f°â³W½d¤§¤Ý¸Þ
„o½×¤½¥­¥æ©öªk²Ä¤Q¤E±ø²Ä¤»´Ú¾A¥Î©ó·f°â¦æ¬°¤§¦X²z©Ê
³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ119
¶L¡B·f°â¦æ¬°³W¨î¤§ªk«ß°ò¦»P²z½×¬[ºc¡þ121
°Ñ¡B¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|·f°â³W½d¤§¹ê°È¹B§@¤ÀªR¡þ128
¸v¡B¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|·f°â³W½d¤§°ÝÃDÂI»Pª¼ÂI¡þ147
¥î¡B¤½¥­¥æ©öªk²Ä¤Q¤E±ø²Ä¤»´Ú¤£¾A©y§@¬°·f°â³W½d¤§¨Ì¾Ú¤Î¥¼¨ÓÀ³¦³¤§³W½d§@¬°¡þ160
³°¡B¥Nµ²½×„oÀ³¦A«ä¯Áªº´X­Ó·f°â³W½d°ÝÃD¡þ165

¤½¥­¥æ©öªk²Ä¤G¤Q¤T±ø¤£·í¦h¼h¦¸¶Ç¾P¡u¥D­n¡v¡B¡u¦X²z¥«»ù¡v¤G¶µ­n¥ó¤§¤ÀªR
„oµû¥qªk°|¤jªk©xÄÀ¦r²Ä¤»¡³¤G¸¹¸ÑÄÀ
³ü¡B¸ÑÄÀ¤å¤Î²z¥Ñ¡þ171
¶L¡Bµû ªR¡þ174

PART II¡þWHEN COMPETITION LAW MEETS INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW

±M§Q±ÂÅv»P¤½¥­¥æ©öªk
„o¥H©Úµ´±ÂÅv»P±j¨î±ÂÅv¬°¤¤¤ß
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ207
¶L¡B¤½¥­¥æ©öªk²Ä¥|¤Q¤­±ø³W©w¤§©w¦ì»P·N¸q¡þ210
°Ñ¡B©Úµ´±ÂÅv»P¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¡þ216
¸v¡B¤½¥­¥æ©öªk»P±M§Qªk¤W¤§±j¨î±ÂÅv¡þ222
¥î¡Bµ² »y¡þ225

°ê¥Á¤¤¤p¾Ç±Ð¬ì®Ñ¡B°Ñ¦Ò®Ñ¥«³õÄvª§¦æ¬°»P¤½¥­¥æ©öªk
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ229
¶L¡B±Ð¬ì®Ñ¡B°Ñ¦Ò®Ñ¥«³õÄvª§¤§¯S®í©Ê¤Î¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¤§³W½d¡þ232
°Ñ¡B±Ð¬ì®Ñ¥«³õ¹ï°Ñ¦Ò®Ñ¥«³õ¤§¼vÅT¤Î¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¤§³W½d¡þ247
¸v¡BµÛ§@Åvªk¹ï±Ð¬ì®Ñ¡B°Ñ¦Ò®Ñ¥«³õ¤§¼vÅT»P¥i¯àªº§ï­²¤è¦V¡þ266
¥î¡Bµ² »y¡þ273

±M§Q¶°ºÞ¡]Patent Pool¡^»P¤½¥­¥æ©öªk
„oµû¦æ¬F°|¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|¹ï­¸§Q®úµ¥¤T®a¨Æ·~§Þ³N±ÂÅv¦æ¬°¤§¤G¦¸³B¤À®×
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¤Î³B¤À²z¥Ñ¡þ277
¶L¡BµûÄÀ„o³B¤À¥D¤å¤Î²z¥Ñ¡A§¡ÃøÃÙ¦P¡þ283
°Ñ¡Bµ² »y¡þ326

§Þ³N¼Ð·Ç»P±M§QÁp·ù¤¤¿W¥e¦a¦ì¤§¨ú±o¤Î¨äÀݥήɤ§±ÏÀÙ±¹¬Iªì±´
„o„o¬ü°êÁp¨¹¥æ©ö©e­û·|In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.®×¤§±Ò¥Ü
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ331
¶L¡BIn the Matter of Rambus, Inc.®×¤§¤¶²Ð¡þ333
°Ñ¡B¿W¥e¦a¦ì¤§»{©w°ÝÃD¡þ337
¸v¡B¿W¥e¦a¦ìÀݥήɤ§±ÏÀÙ±¹¬I¡þ346
¥î¡Bµ² »y¡þ351

¤½¥­¥æ©öªk²Ä¤G¤Q±ø²Ä¤@¡B¤G¶µ¡uªí¼x¡v¤§·N¸q¤Î¨ä»P·s¦¡¼Ë±M§Q«OÅ@¤§Ãö«Y
„o„oµû³Ì°ª¦æ¬Fªk°|¤E¤Q¤G¦~§P¦r²Ä¤@¤»¥|¤E¸¹§P¨M
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ355
¶L¡B§P¨M²z¥Ñ¡þ356
°Ñ¡Bµû ªR¡þ359
¸v¡Bµ² »y¡þ392

¡u¬K¤ô°ó¡vªí¼x¤§´¶¹M»{ª¾©Ê¤Î²V²c¤§¦³µL
„o„o¥x¥_°ªµ¥¦æ¬Fªk°|¤E¤Q¥|¦~¶D§ó¤@¦r²Ä¡³¡³¡³¡³¤E¸¹§P¨MµûªR
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ397
¶L¡B§P¨M²z¥Ñ¡þ398
°Ñ¡B§P¨MµûªR¡þ400
¸v¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ420

¤½¥q¦WºÙ¤§¤H®æÅv«OÅ@»P°Ó¼Ðªk¡B¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¶¡¤§ªÈ¸¯
¡þµû¥xÆW°ªµ¥ªk°|¤E¤Q¤»¦~«×¤W§óüæ¦r²Ä¤@¤G¤»¸¹
¡uªF´Ë¤£°Ê²£¥ò¤¶¸g¬ö¦³­­¤½¥q¡vvs.¡uªF´Ë«Ø·~¤£°Ê²£¥ò¤¶¸g¬öªÑ¥÷¦³­­¤½¥q¡v§P¨M
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ425
¶L¡B§P¨M²z¥Ñ¡þ428
°Ñ¡B§P¨MµûªR¡þ429
¸v¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ459

´¼¼z°]²£«I®`ĵ§i¨ç»P¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¤§¾A¥Î
„o±M§QÅvÅv§Q¦æ¨Ï¤§·N¸q»P¬É­­
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ463
¶L¡B¡u¼f²z¨Æ·~µo«I®`µÛ§@Åv¡B°Ó¼ÐÅv©Î±M§QÅvĵ§i¨ç®×¥ó³B²z­ì«h¡v¡þ467
°Ñ¡B¬ü°ê¤Ï¦«©Ô´µªk¤§Noerr-Penningtonªk²z¡þ478
¸v¡B¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|¹ê°È¹B§@¤§ª¼ÂI¡þ492
¥î¡B¤½¥­¥æ©ö©e­û·|¹ê°È¹B§@¤§°ÝÃDÂI¡þ501
³°¡Bµ² »y¡þ510

ªþ¥ó¡þ512

¥\¯à©Ê¥ßÅé°Ó¼Ð»P±M§QÅv«OÅ@¶¡¤§Äv¦X»P½Õ©M
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ517
¶L¡B°Ó¼Ðªk¹ï¥ßÅé°Ó¼Ð¤§³W½d¡þ520
°Ñ¡B¥ßÅé°Ó¼Ð»P±M§Q¨î«×¡þ528
¸v¡Bµ² ½×¡þ540

PART III¡þINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW AND ITS FUTURE

«~µP¥xÆWµo®i­pµe»P°Ó¼Ðªk¨î¦]À³¤§¹D
„o„o¡þ¶W¶VWTO/TRIPS³W½d¡B¨V¨ú¦Û¥Ñ¶T©öÅé¨t³Ì¤j§Q¯q
³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ549
¶L¡Bªñ¦~¨Ó°Ó¼Ðªk¨î­×¥¿¦^ÅU¡þ552
°Ñ¡B«~½è«OÃÒ¥\¯à»P°Ó¼Ðªk³W½d¤§²z½×»P¹ê»Ú¡þ558
¸v¡B°Ó¼Ðªk»P¤½¥­¥æ©öªk¤§Äv¦X¤Î¨ä¦]À³¤§¹D¡þ569
¥î¡B¸gÀÙ§Q¥Î¤§³W½d¡þ575
³°¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ582

±M§Q«IÅv·l®`½ßÀv¶D³^¡u¬G·N¡B¹L¥¢¡v¤§­n§_»P·l®`ÃB¤§­pºâ¤è¦¡
„o¡þµû³Ì°ªªk°|¤E¤Q¤T¦~«×¥x¤W¦r²Ä¤G¤G¤E¤G¸¹§P¨M
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ587
¶L¡B§P¨M²z¥Ñ¡þ588
°Ñ¡Bµû ªR¡þ590

±M§Qªk²Ä¤K¤Q¤­±ø²Ä¤@¶µ²Ä¤G´Ú¥H¡u«I®`¦æ¬°©Ò±o¤§§Q¯q¡v­pºâ·l®`³W©w¤§ªk«ß©w¦ì¡B¥\ ¯à»P¾A¥Î
„o„o¡þµû³Ì°ªªk°|¤E¤Q¤C¦~«×¥x¤W¦r²Ä¤G¤G¤C¸¹§P¨M
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ619
¶L¡B§P¨M²z¥Ñ¡þ621
°Ñ¡B§P¨MµûªR¡þ622
¸v¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ650

¡uµn°O¹ï§Ü¥D¸q¡v»µºq
„o„o¡þµû³Ì°ªªk°|¤E¤Q¤»¦~«×¥x¤W¦r²Ä¤@¤»¤­¤K¸¹§P¨M
³ü¡B¨Æ¹ê·§­n¡þ655
¶L¡B§P¨M²z¥Ñ¡þ656
°Ñ¡B§P¨MµûªR¡þ658
¸v¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ683

±M§Qªk­×¥¿«á±M§Qª§³^¨î«×À³¦³¤§§ï­²
„o¥H±M§QÅv®Ä¤Oª§³^µ{§Ç¬°¤¤¤ß
³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ687
¶L¡B§Ú°ê²{¦æ±M§QÅv®Ä¤Oª§³^µ{§Ç¤§ºc³y¡þ690
°Ñ¡B¥~°êªk¨î¦³Ãö±M§QÅv®Ä¤O¤§ª§³^µ{§Ç³]­p¡þ697
¸v¡B±M§QÅv®Ä¤Oª§³^¨î«×À³¦³¤§²z©À»P°t®M±¹¬I¡þ705
¥î¡B±M§QÅv®Ä¤Oª§³^¨î«×§ï­²¤è¦V»P§@ªk¡þ714
³°¡Bµ² »y¡þ720

¤é¥»µÛ§@Åvªk¨îµo®i¯S¦â¤Î¹ï§Ú°êµÛ§@Åvªk¥¼¨Óµo®i¤§±Ò¥Ü
³ü¡B«e ¨¥¡þ725
¶L¡B¤é¥»µÛ§@Åvªk¨î¤§¤@¯ë³W½d¯S¦â¡þ726
°Ñ¡B¤é¥»µÛ§@Åvªk¨î¤§¨ãÅé³W½d¯S¦â¡þ730
¸v¡B¥Nµ²½×„o¤é¥»µÛ§@Åvªk¨îµo®i¹ï§Ú°êµÛ§@Åvªk¤§±Ò¥Ü¡þ744